Mississippi ranks among the best states when it comes to enacting laws against drunken driving. As do Maryland and Nebraska, according to a new report by Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD). Texas gets a 2.5 ranking in the 1 to 5 survey.
MADD’s other criteria include using high-profile law enforcement efforts against drunken driving, such as sobriety checkpoints and saturation patrols; immediately suspending licenses or otherwise restricting driving privileges following a DUI arrest; penalizing drivers who refuse to submit to a breath test; and passing laws that impose additional penalties on drunk drivers who had a child in the car with them at the time.
MADD, by using half stars, also attempted to gauge the degree of aggressiveness a jurisdiction’s use of a policy is — for example, whether a state not only conducts sobriety checkpoints but does so at least once a month.
In the Washington metropolitan region, Maryland came out on top with a score of 4.5 stars, falling short of a perfect 5 only because the state, like most, classifies drunken driving with a child passenger as a misdemeanor instead of a felony. The District received a 3-star rating, Virginia 3.5 stars.
Frank Harris, MADD’s director of state government affairs, said the variation among the states’ approach to drunken driving generally aligns with cultural norms and their view of government’s role. States that tend to be more libertarian or embrace the philosophy that the government that governs least also governs best are also less likely to embrace the use of sobriety checkpoints, for example, as those are seen by some as intrusive.
“Some of that is just mind-set,” Harris said in an interview. But he said checkpoints are also effective and have been shown to reduce drunken driving by 20 percent.
MADD says data suggest that the push for ignition interlock devices for all offenders has also paid off. Ten years ago, the advocacy group launched a campaign to reduce drunken driving after statistics showed that progress had slowed.
At the time, only New Mexico had enacted what MADD calls an “all-offender” ignition interlock law. Today, 28 states, along with the District of Columbia, require ignition interlocks after the first offense. Twenty-five states and the District also require evidence of continuing compliance before the devices can be removed.
In 2006, drunk drivers caused more than 13,000 fatalities, or about 32 percent of all crashes. As of 2016, the number of drunken driving fatalities has fallen 24 percent, accounting for more than 10,000 deaths and 29 percent of all traffic fatalities every year.